Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Miami Meltdown: Tempers Flare As Pacers Hammer Heat

New England Revolution Offseason 2012: Getting On Board

FOXBORO, MA - JULY 17:  Fans of the New England Revolution show their support before a game against Philadelphia Union at Gillette Stadium on July 17, 2011 in Foxboro, Massachusetts. (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images)

Perhaps it is the remnants of the last two seasons that has Revolution supporters feeling incredibly negative about the franchise's off-season moves. With news of players reneging on deals, choosing to sign in different countries, being defined as unnecessary to the organization, or threatening retirement, it is easy to let surprisingly positive moves get whitewashed in negativity. However, the New England Revolution have had a better off-season than people are giving them credit for.

So while the stories of Rajko Lekic, Monsef Zerka, and Milton Caraglio - who apparently have become the symbols of front office failures to many supporters - led the Revs off-season news-line, the more recent "failures" have Revolution supporters more on edge than usual. Sure it is easy to point out the so-called atrocities of the front office and say that they are failing at their jobs (I know I've done it), but that is only looking at half the story.

Star-divide

Yes, many of us were upset at seeing Danleigh Borman turn down a deal and sign in South Africa. And sure, every Revs supporter was up in arms over the Jose Moreno story. And then, of course, the news that Nate Jaqua may be thinking that retirement is a better deal than suiting up for New England hit. It seemed to be exactly how the off-season was going. Just epic failure after epic failure. But while New England has yet to sign that big-named DP, their silly season has had some seriously overlooked good news.

While I for one was hoping the FO would pick up Chandler Hoffman in the SuperDraft with the third pick, the Revs did make a wise selection in choosing Hoffman's UCLA teammate Kelyn Rowe. In addition to Rowe, the Revolution lucked out by having Tyler Polak basically fall into their laps with the 22nd pick. That is two Generation Adidas players, who have both earned caps for the USMNT U20 squad. One is a solid creator, and the other is that rare MLS left-footed left back. Both could contribute in their first year, but more importantly, neither will count against the cap, leaving room for other moves.

Looking towards the crap-shoot that is the Re-Entry Draft, we saw the FO pick up three players. And while Borman chose to sign with SuportSport United FC of the South African Premier Soccer League, and Nate Jaqua may be looking to retire, the Revolution did come away with Clyde Simms. When analyzing these picks, we can see that Borman was still raw and Jaqua seemed to be past his prime, but Simms - who last year was still earning starting minutes for D.C. United - could provide either excellent cover for Shalrie Joseph or possibly a second DM in a double-pivot midfield. That is not a horrendous pick-up for a draft whose role in MLS player acquisition is still being defined.

And while Moreno may be the Colombian that is seen as the defining point of the Revolutions off-season, John Lozano and Fernando Cárdenas, both formerly of América de Cali, are being highly overlooked. These two quality players could have immediate dividends for the Revs. Last season we saw glimpses of what A.J. Soares could be, and John Lozano may just be that high quality CB to further his development that supporters are looking for. Leonel Alvarez has referred to Cárdenas as "a magician with the ball," and if you check out his youtube clips (which granted I could probably throw together some clips of me playing and make myself look pretty damn good), he has tinges of a young David Ferreira (who was also spent a good portion of his young career with América de Cali). This could potentially add yet another creator to the line-up.

But where will the goals come from? The thought I've often had is if you have people who can create chances then any moron will be able to knock in goals. The FO has, thus far, taken two chances. The first was Moreno. And while this looks to become messier and messier every day, the fact is the FO took a chance. The chance may fail, but maybe it will work out. The second chance they took is on Saer Sene. While Sène's connection to Bayern Munich might be overstated, the reports of him being able to take defenders on one-on-one, having good feet, and getting on the end of balls seem positive. These attributes could help him greatly up top in front of a midfield featuring the likes of Cárdenas, Feilhaber, Rowe, and even Shalrie (who is much more of a creator than he is ever given credit for).

All of this doesn't even take into account that despite stories leaking via Twitter last year, the FO was still able to re-sign Shalrie Joseph to a big contract, which will hopefully let him remain a Rev for the remainder of his MLS career. Nor is it looking at Ryan Kinne's recent positive statements about Jay Heaps or additional growth for Diego Fagundez.

So no, the Revolution have not signed Didier Drogba, Alessandro Del Piero, or Michael Ballack, but the front office has made some intriguing moves. We may sit and moan about mistakes, yet that is just what comes with being a supporters. No matter what the FO does they will never make 100% of the supporters happy. However, it appears that despite the overwhelming negative opinions to three stories (Re-Entry Draft, Lekic-Caraglio-Zerka, and Moreno) there are reasons to stay positive. And at the end of the day, isn't creating a reason for hope what the off-season should be all about?

Poll
Which Revs player are you most excited about for the 2012 season?
Fernando Cardenas
1 votes
Diego Fagundez
4 votes
Benny Feilhaber
14 votes
Shalrie Joseph
0 votes
John Lozano
0 votes
Tyler Polak
0 votes
Matt Reis
1 votes
Kelyn Rowe
27 votes
Clyde Simms
0 votes
Other
3 votes

50 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 17 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

until the Revs sign some quality FW options most of the rest is inconsequential.

I asked a guy I know about Cardenas and he said he’d never really established himself anywhere despite good ball skills. Posisble attitude issue?

by Alan Clark on Feb 15, 2012 4:13 PM EST reply actions  

Agreed

There does need to be a proven striker for this team. Could it be Sene? Maybe, but I’d have felt more comfortable if Caraglio OR Lekic was brought back. Still, it hasn’t been a terrible off-season.

As far as Cardenas, I haven’t heard anything about attitude with him. I honestly can’t figure out how he couldn’t get time, because everything I’ve read about him has been glowing -perhaps too glowing. Maybe it’s a change of scenery, but I like the little I’ve seen of him.

Contributor: The Bent Musket on SBNation.
Founder: Viva La Futbol
Twitter: @MindOfAbram

by Abram Chamberlain on Feb 15, 2012 4:26 PM EST up reply actions  

It's actually difficult

to pick just one player in your poll! I ended up choosing Kelyn for his impressive performances all preseason so far. This stacked midfield will be interesting because it will cause healthy competition for spots with all legitimately good players. Look at the players who can play out wide: Guy, Tierney, Nyassi, Mansally, Kinne, Rowe, Cardenas, Purdie (who I believe will and should be signed), and Benny if needed (though he is better as a CAM). I think what was brought up earlier is that Keyln’s GA status may affect his time and the fact that Cardenas is loan to buy and eating up and international spot, the Revs may want to get their money’s worth by playing him often even if there are better wingers on this team. I also hope Tierney can get time on the left wing. His free kicks are deadly and his crossses are good but I still have the feeling the Revs aren’t ready for Polak at left back just yet and Tierney may still be asked to play there unfortunately.

And finally, with all these chances, like you said, there’s no way guys like Sene, Brettschnieder (if signed) and even Schilawski can’t knock them in often, that is if the midfielders don’t score themselves!

by cbrown4747 on Feb 15, 2012 7:14 PM EST reply actions  

GA $ Saved? Who care!

for the people thinking that Rowe is the new savior, take a step back. Pre-season is just that. Wait and see before thinking it was a great pick.

Adam, your statement about the GA costing nothing is naive. None of the players under the max cost nothing. It is league money. The F.O. has shown NO DESIRE to spend even that money on real players.

Until thye prove me wrong and force me to eat crow, the off-season is nothing less than an EPIC failure. No rose colored glasses would change that.

Now if you take the current roster and add back Lekic, Caraglio and Zerka, now it would look like a decent off-season.

Can you honestly say that the new players are better than the ones who left? I cannot.

And (dark) food for thoughts. I have seen and analysis of MLS for European players looking for MLS gigs. It ranks the Revs last or second to last on thing like stadium, management, general local interest, fan support and game atmosphere. That make me really sad.

by ExiledinUSA on Feb 15, 2012 7:51 PM EST reply actions  

If you can find that analysis, link it

I’ve heard of it, too, but I’ve never seen it

Founder and Editor of The Bent Musket on SBNation.
Twitter: @Stoehrst or @TheBentMusket

by Steve Stoehr on Feb 15, 2012 8:35 PM EST up reply actions  

I cannot

I had access to a confidential PDF though someone I know who acts as an agent. It was done all new frontier markets in soccer. It had the same analysis for China, Qatar, UAE.
Basically, it is designed to help the players learn about where they are going for that last pay check.

by ExiledinUSA on Feb 16, 2012 10:28 AM EST up reply actions  

I like what Rowe could bring -key word being could. I still am a Hoffman fan and think that would have made more sense. And yes, pre-season against D5 and college teams is one thing. We’ll probably have a better picture of what he can bring once the Desert Diamond Cup is done.

Also, there’s a difference between GA players being free, and GA players not counting against the cap. I said they didn’t count against the cap, which leaves room for additional player to be fit into MLS’s restrictive salary cap.

You can’t really call it an epic failure, that is just being negative for the sake of being negative. They strengthened the midfield and the backline, the big problem is still up top. Could Sene be the answer? Maybe, but we won’t know with him until we see him against MLS competition.

I absolutely agree with Lekic and Caraglio -not so much with Zerka. If one of those two were our FW going in I’d be much more comfortable.

Finally, you can never tell if the new players will be better than the ones who left until they play MLS games -preseason or otherwise. I would put money on Lozano being a step up from Barnes at CB, and Cárdenas being a step up from Mansally, Nyassi, and Tierney. Simms isn’t replacing anyone, per say, but we do know he is a solid MLS player.

As for the food for thought, I haven’t seen/read/heard this analysis, but it wouldn’t surprise me. However, if New England announced a play to build a SSS tomorrow they would still need players to fill it. If the FO announced a new SSS in Lower Roxbury, South Boston, Somerville, or even Revere tomorrow it wouldn’t matter if the product on the field was bad.

In my opinion, and based on what I’ve heard/read/seen, the team is rebuilding in Heaps’ mold, they are playing the ball on the ground, and trying to keep possession. Will they compete for SS or MLS Cup this year? Probably not, they might not even compete for a playoff spot. What I want to see is an improved product, and it looks like they’re aiming to do this.

Contributor: The Bent Musket on SBNation.
Founder: Viva La Futbol
Twitter: @MindOfAbram

by Abram Chamberlain on Feb 16, 2012 10:50 AM EST up reply actions  

Possession

Every coach I know, heard or read about these days is about possession. Very few wants to play the long ball or the catenaccio. They might be forced to do it because of lack of talent. Nicol preached possession last year and they were basically a long ball to nowhere team.

Do you really think our team has the technical skills to maintain possession in this league? I do not know.

by ExiledinUSA on Feb 16, 2012 2:14 PM EST up reply actions  

I don't think Nicol has the coaching skills for a possession game

Not that he’s a bad coach, but that’s just not him, I think. That’s not to say that he wants all his teams to play like Stoke – the Revs of the mid-2000s did their fair share of pretty passing – but his system is a fairly traditional and rigid pass-and-move that you used to see a lot of in England in the 80s and 90s. If he had incredible talent with him, I’m sure they could have possessed, but some coaches will institute a system that you’ll see work even with mediocre talent around, just because those coaches are good at drilling in that system.

Founder and Editor of The Bent Musket on SBNation.
Twitter: @Stoehrst or @TheBentMusket

by Steve Stoehr on Feb 16, 2012 3:40 PM EST up reply actions  

Lekic/Caraglio/Zerka

As upset as we are about losing them, let’s not forget that with them we were in the cellar still. But the point is that WITH those three added to the players brought in already, it’d at least be a start to a stronger side. However, if Caraglio and Co. were brought back, would we have seen Sene/Cardenas/Lozano ?

Contributor to SBNation Blog "The Bent Musket", covering all things New England Revolution.

by Matty Jollie on Feb 16, 2012 9:37 AM EST reply actions  

Why Not?

Why could we have them all? There is a lot of dead weight on the roster: Boggs, Schilawski, McCarthy, Mansally, Nyassi, Shuttelworth and I will stop here. Our caring and beloved F.O. decided to get rid of the better players and keep the terrible ones because it is what the fan base wants.

by ExiledinUSA on Feb 16, 2012 10:30 AM EST up reply actions  

The devil you know...

I loved Lekic, thought Caraglio could be huge, and enjoyed what Zerka brought in his limited time, but you hit the nail on the head with the Revs still being terrible with them. It’s easy to fantasize about them automatically making the team better. However, until we know what our new guys bring we won’t be able to fairy assess whether the FO truly did make good or bad moves. I’m just glad they are making moves and making chances on younger players, as opposed to the much older players they’ve brought to Foxborough in the past.

Contributor: The Bent Musket on SBNation.
Founder: Viva La Futbol
Twitter: @MindOfAbram

by Abram Chamberlain on Feb 16, 2012 10:54 AM EST up reply actions  

Compare

Another way to evaluate the FO Fantastically Wonderfully Positive off season is to compare to the other teams in the league. Name me the team you think did a worse job that our beloved FO, at least on paper?

A lot of teams got really stronger and the ones who did not were already strong. I think the only one I think has done an awful job this off season is Philadelphia. They lost Mondragon and traded Le Toux for $. Not good move in my opinion.

The one thing which I think we might underestimate is the reputation of the Revs in and out of the league. Do you think they are a team players wants to play for the wat LA and NY are?

by ExiledinUSA on Feb 16, 2012 2:11 PM EST reply actions  

I'm not sure NY has had the best offseason either

As loaded as they are on paper, they REALLY, REALLY aren’t in good shape, or weren’t going into the offseason. Then they lose Rost and Tim Ream, and they’re gonna have to do what they can on bargain-bin goalkeepers (Robles would be a good move, though). So I’d put them down below us. I’m not sure what Toronto has done, although they were on the upswing going into the offseason. Vancouver has re-tooled but they still have defensive questions, Chivas is an unknown. You’re right about one thing – most of the good teams have stayed good.

Founder and Editor of The Bent Musket on SBNation.
Twitter: @Stoehrst or @TheBentMusket

by Steve Stoehr on Feb 16, 2012 3:41 PM EST up reply actions  

It's about teams with similar records

Looking at the teams who had similar records to the Revs (San Jose, Chivas, Toronto, and Vancouver), I’d say only Vancouver had a better off-season than the Revs. San Jose’s biggest move was bringing back Dawkins and praying that Lenhart and Opara have good form. Chivas, as Steve said, who knows. TFC didn’t do much, but I’d expect them to have a surprisingly good season based on their form at the end of last year.

Above this group were DC, PDX, CHI, NY, Columbus, Colorado, and Dallas. PDX and maybe DC got significantly better the rest pretty much, so far, have been treading water. You may even be able to argue that Columbus and NY got worse.

It’s all about perspective. The Revs aren’t going to go from last (technically second to last) to Supporters Shield, or even playoffs, in one off-season. Rebuilding takes time. They’ve made a lot of steps, and for once, took some big chances. Now we need to see if the chances pay off.

Contributor: The Bent Musket on SBNation.
Founder: Viva La Futbol
Twitter: @MindOfAbram

by Abram Chamberlain on Feb 16, 2012 10:38 PM EST up reply actions  

bad shape is relative

As badly as NY was perceived, they still madethe playoffs and upsetted Dallas before falling to LA after competing with them. The big problem for NY is Marquez who is singlehandely destroying the locker room. And they have not addressed it.

But they got Conde from Chicago, Thierry coming back of a good stint with Arsenal and they do have an owner willing to spend if needed.

I think they are in a better shape than we are and I said early, I would trade owner and FO in a NY second.

by ExiledinUSA on Feb 16, 2012 4:41 PM EST reply actions  

Lot of variables for NY

Is Conde still good? How is the Marquez situation going to play out? How is the Backe situation going to play out? Does Kenny Cooper work? Is Rodgers coming? Who is the goalie? New York is very talented 1-11 (actually more like 1-9), but there is a deep fall off after that, and a manager who doesn’t want to use the bench anyway. That said, Henry is probably enough to single-handedly pull them into the playoffs.

Contributor: The Bent Musket on SBNation.
Founder: Viva La Futbol
Twitter: @MindOfAbram

by Abram Chamberlain on Feb 16, 2012 10:40 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

The Bent Musket is an in-depth look at the New England Revolution by fans like us. We will feature news, interviews, match reports and opinion, with occasional forays into greater New England soccer.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Stadium Location and Attendance
Small
Portland misfired all day
Small
STH Meeting

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Regiment Commander

Headshot_1_small Steve Stoehr

Cavalry

_corey_small Corey E. Major

Musketeers

N1145234711_30219220_7116_small Matty Jollie

Profile2_small Abram Chamberlain

TheIndirectKick